Almost 1 in 3 of the products that Amazon promoted as Black Friday and Cyber Monday ‘deals’ in 2024 and 2025 were priced at the same or higher than they had been in the month prior to the sale, according to an investigative report from Groundwork Collaborative. They compared the sale prices on 351 items from Amazon’s deals pages to the lowest price that Keepa had recorded on Amazon in the previous 30 days. Nearly 1 in 10 of those ‘deals’ were actually higher. You might want to keep this in mind for this year’s Black Friday sale.
An Apple Watch Series 10 “on sale” for $679.99 during Black Friday 2025 had been $602 a month earlier, so buyers effectively paid about $78 more. Men’s UGG Butte boots were a $179.98 Cyber Monday “deal,” having been $98.40 just a few weeks prior. The Beats Solo 4’s “on sale” price of $129.95 had already been that price 12 days before Black Friday. Even after Groundwork had ignored the lows of the week prior, 1 in 5 of the featured deals were still no cheaper.
Amazon calls the report flawed
In a statement on November 16, Amazon called the claims “deeply flawed and false”. 350 items are a tiny fraction of the over 10m deals available, and 98% of the products were at the same price or lower than the price over the prior 30 days. Amazon also pointed out that some of the earlier lows were, in fact, Early Event deals and that some of the items were never even badged as deals in the store. Groundwork stated that all the products came from Amazon’s sale event pages. That said, the company is tightening rules for upcoming sales to ensure event deals will almost always be better than the prior 30-day low.
Check last month’s price, not the badge
The European Union requires a seller advertising a discount to show its own lowest price from the prior 30 days. The US has no comparable federal rule. Amazon says Alexa can show up to a year of price history, a feature Digital Trends has already covered, and the tool is not limited to Prime members. Keepa and CamelCamelCamel offer free charts of the same data. A crossed-out list price can be a manufacturer’s suggested price, or a price Amazon or another retailer charged as far back as 90 to 180 days, according to Amazon.
Simply put, check the pricing history before you score a “deal.”







